May 15, 2009

Two unrelated Schuyler stories


Red again
Originally uploaded by Citizen Rob

1) Condolences

Last week, I received an email from one of Schuyler's teachers. Actually, it was one of those e-cards, and along with the music, the condolences message and the animated candle, there was a note. "Schuyler told me that your father had passed away and I wanted you to know that you and your family are in my thoughts and prayers."

It was a very sweet message. It really made me kind of sad to have to write her back and say that while yes, it's true that my father passed away, it wasn't exactly a fresh tragedy in our lives. My dad died in 1990.

I'm not sure why, but Schuyler is a little obsessed with the topic of my father's death. I think the asymmetry bothers her, for one thing. She has a mother and a father, and so does Julie. The fact that I do not seems to bug Schuyler.

It's also the only real-world death that she's ever had to think about. Being Schuyler, she thinks about it a lot. She turns it over and over in her head, trying to make it fit in her world, like a puzzle piece. I've never shied away from the topic with her, and so she freely (and often) asks questions. When we drove past a huge, beautiful Jewish cemetery in Brooklyn, she asked if my dad was there. When she sees someone sick on television, she will ask me "Like your dad?" It's one of the reasons I have decided to delay my book about fatherhood for a few years. I think she might have something interesting to say about the topic when she's a little older.

Recently, Schuyler asked me if my father is a zombie or a mummy. Perhaps I need to start paying closer attention to what she watches on television.

-----

2) Frenemy

It took me years (and the arrival of the Internet) to get my own, but Schuyler is ahead of the curve.

At the age of nine, she has her first nemesis.

They started off as friends, and if you ask Schuyler on a good day, she'll insist that they're not just friends, but close friends at that. This girl joined Schuyler's AAC class this year, and for the longest time, she and Schuyler were inseparable. They seem close in skill level, and they're both ambulatory, so it seemed natural for them to become friends, especially since Schuyler's previous best friend no longer attends her school.

Over the course of the year, however, the relationship has grown... complicated.

Now they can't leave each other alone, but as often as not, they are antagonizing each other. They disrupt class, they insult each other and are intensely competitive. When her friend gets upset, Schuyler knows exactly how to push her buttons and keep her in a state of anxiety. The stories that come home to us don't even sound like Schuyler anymore.

They sound like me.

It's been a recurring state of affairs for the past few weeks, and at this point we all seem like we just want to run out the clock on the semester and start fresh next year. Schuyler had a particularly rough day yesterday after trying to get her little frenemy in trouble, and it's going to be a long weekend of no TV, no computer and no hamster. (Swee has moved into our room for now, and last night I got an answer to a question I've had since we got him. Yes, he does use his wheel at night. A lot.)

Last week, Schuyler got in trouble at school during an argument with her friend in which the insults escalated to them calling each other "stupid". That's obviously a troubling word for them to be throwing around, especially since as special education students, it's one that they get to hear from the rest of the world enough as it is. I confess that I have developed a kind of prejudice against neurotypical kids, as hard as I try not to. I see a few of them snub Schuyler at her after school program when she tries to tell her "friends" goodbye, too cool to be seen talking to the Weird Girl. It's only a few of them, but it still makes me crazy.

But with her friend, it's hard, because they're both on the same side of that fight. "Stupid" is a word that I hate to hear her use against another SpEd classmate in particular, and so we all sat down and talked for a long time about respect and about the things we should never ever call someone else. I felt like a hypocrite, of course, and I made a little vow to myself to be more careful what I say about other drivers when we're in the car. I guess in that respect, we're lucky she called her friend "stupid" and not something along the lines of "fucknuts".

After our talk, it was obvious Schuyler was thinking about something intensely. She was clearly troubled by something. Finally she said, "Daddy, can I talk to you?"

She says this a lot, for reasons that we're not quite sure of. It feels a little like the movie cliche "Permission to speak candidly, Sir!" I think, however, that it's mostly her way of saying that she's got something important to say, so listen up and pay close attention. She started punching something up on her Big Box of Words, making sure she got her statement just right before speaking. As she activated the speech, she put her hand over her mouth, as if she was speaking forbidden words. I had to look away so she wouldn't see my smirk.

"But I think she is stupid."

She has since recanted that sentiment, but let it never be said that Schuyler can't hold a grudge. I have no idea where she gets it.

-----

Update, 7:00pm

Ugh. She came home today with an even worse note. Apparently during art class, she called her friend's picture "stupid", too. Ironically, she couldn't spell it right for me when I asked her to tell me on her device what she said. She's learning how to spell the word right now, in her room, over and over on a pad of paper, like I had to do when I was a kid. If she loves this word so much, she at least needs to know how to spell it. We're going old skool.

And for the record, I never hate myself more than when I am disciplining her like this.

34 comments:

Christopher said...

I can understand the feeling of wanting to run the school year out.

The girls in my eight grade classroom are at each others' throats on a pretty regular basis now. Friends one day, enemies the next.

We have had to involve parents and make some pretty pretty harsh punishments if the behavior continues.

This is my first year of teaching Jr. High. I have 15 years teaching experience but never higher than 6th grade. I have learned a lot this year.

Good luck and I hope everything works out. If not, there is always eight grade to look forward to.

Elizabeth said...

Yes. It was a sad day in our home when my sons realized that the word "stupid" wasn't actually a curse word. By the way, I am going to poach "fucknuts" for stupid drivers.

Cairsten said...

Oh, oww.

Sadly, she's not ahead of the curve for girls; girls do this to each other all the time starting from about age seven or so. I can promise you that they outgrow it, but separating them before they do too much damage to each other might be a good idea.

Monroegirl said...

Ah, but just to play devil's advocate here, be glad you get to discipline her like this, eh? Kind of cool, in a weird way. Maybe the other girl is stupid. Hee hee. I love the part where she covered her mouth while she showed you. Classic.

watchwhathappens said...

You might enjoy this, then: http://www.groovelily.com/store/songs/little-nemesis-live/

Milehimama said...

Sounds like they're as close as sisters! LOL

I'm a big fan of the sentence writing/paragraph copying/essay method of discipline for some kids.

cd0103 said...

I don't think I love either of you more. This age sucks. Sorry.

cd0103 said...

Make that "could love either of you more".

Sorry

Cecelia said...

I found something for your hamster!

http://www.foundshit.com/hamster-powered-music-box/

Jordan said...

Sorry about your dad...!

I don't know how you could've possibly kept a straight face when she covered her mouth and said that about her frenemy. That was pretty awesome.

Niksmom said...

Definitely typical girl behavior. Sad but true.

Still chortling over "Fucknuts" and will have to try that when I'm in the car (alone!).

Oh, and, um, yeah...sorry about your dad.

Anonymous said...

Don't worry about it too much, it's totally normal. Right at that age, I had another girl like that too - and we were insulting each other's intelligence, projects, reading ability, haircuts, etc. For some reason, the third grade teacher stuck us together in seating arrangements and a project (The Missions of California, how I hate you.)

I know it's weird to you, but ask Julie. Every girl dishes it out and takes it.

That said, it also broke my father's heart.

Sara

Ellen said...

Sabrina has a "frenemy" too, who has taught her to say things to me like "You're a bad lady!" and, worse, "YOU'RE FIRED!!!!!" Not stuff a four-year-old should be telling her mom, eh? Little girls can be evil in ways that little boys just aren't.

I have to say, your description of Schuyler's obssession with death made me smile. She has such a curious, inventive mind, it wouldn't surprise me if she turned out to be a writer, too. Has she ever mentioned starting her own blog?

Kyla said...

My son and my little sister-in-law (they are a year apart in age) have a frenemistic relationship. It makes us CRAZY. He always ends up in trouble when we visit them.

So, IS your dad a zombie?

Phoebe Caulfield said...

Oh man. That post takes me back. I had a neighborhood frenemy at Schuyler's age. It escalated into me losing my temper and scratching her neck on the bus. My mom just loved getting that phone call...

Schuyler will probably have one or two frenemies off and on through high school. It's called relational aggression. Girls have a lot of conflict because they're supposed to be nice and friendly and sweet, but when they don't like someone they've been taught to express it passive-aggressively. The Ophelia Project works with this and might have some resources to help you help Schuyler
http://www.opheliaproject.org

Rob Rummel-Hudson said...

Thank you, Phoebe, that site is extremely helpful!

Karen said...

I do not envy you the next handful of years. Girls start with the catty ways about this age and it continues into the teens. I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but sadly it's true. Hopefully it's short lived for you.

Nancy in Calif. said...

(whoops)

Sorry to hear you're struggling with this pretty normal phase. When Schuyler gets to be 13, I'm going to stop reading your blog for a few years.

One word for Swee: earplugs.

In other news, I just gave away my last autographed copy of the book to my top physiology student for the semester. That means you have to come back to California so I can restock. Just thought you'd like to know, for scheduling purposes!

Suzanne said...

Love the lyrics on the Little Nemesis song! Nice.

1) I remember being somewhat the same way about death. My paternal grandfather and maternal great-grandmother both died the year before I was born and I think I had a tough time with that as a kid. I remember seeing pictures of my older brother with both of them and wishing I'd had that. My only other experience with death by Schuyler's age was my aunt's cat that disappeared when I was just 2 years old. My grandmother and I went out walking to look for him and we found him dead on the side of the road (obviously hit by a car). I remember talking about that for years and mentally relating that to my grandfather and my minimal understanding of death.

Sadly, at 10, I lost a close friend in a fire. I think that's when it really all sunk in for me. I hope Schuyler's questions and your answers help her to better understand and she doesn't have to lose someone close any time soon!

2) The frenemy thing is tough. I think my first one was in the 5th grade. I don't remember ever calling her names, but I do remember having sort of a love-hate relationship. We were all bused over to another school once a week for a gifted program (You know... any way to alienate the "different" kids whether SpEd or gifted is always beneficial. Urg). One day when she'd done something to piss me off, I hid her spelling book in a different cubby... of course thinking I'd give it back to her at the end of the day. Well, I forgot. Her book was stuck over there for a week. I got in trouble, had to give her my book, and got points docked from all of my work for it being late... since I had no book.

Ah... the trials and tribulations of elementary school and difficult friendships. On a random note, that friend and I are now connected through Facebook... 24 years later!

Now to stop procrastinating and stop boring the world with my inane ramblings, and get back to my Acoustic Analysis of Speech homework.

Hope the frenemy stuff chills out soon so they can both focus on school (or the summer, if that's what works).

Karen said...

I like the permission to speak. My kids (teens!) ask permission to use the bathroom. I always have an urge to say no.

I also like her saying that she still thought she was stupid. It may not be politically correct, appropriate, or even acceptable. But it's good that she wants to say what she thinks and feels. I worry more about kids who won't stand up for themselves.

I'm sorry to hear you say that you've developed a prejudice against neurotypical kids. But it's good that you're fighting it. There are some great kid (and awful kids) of almost every variety on the planet.

Anonymous said...

"Sadly, she's not ahead of the curve for girls; girls do this to each other all the time starting from about age seven or so. I can promise you that they outgrow it, but separating them before they do too much damage to each other might be a good idea."

Hate to break it to you, but they don't. Exhibit A: Movie: "Mean Girls" Exhibit B: 90% Of every girl I knew from Grade 2 to now, including my 36 year old boss.

You're really right, Phoebe. It's frustrating. I hope that Schuyler grows up well adjusted enough to know how to handle these kinds of situations. She's really lucky that the internet can provide such valuable resources. Because Brownies and Girl Scouts didn't do me a bit of good.

At the same time, it's kind of a rite of passage, you know? We all kind of need the sucky moments of childhood to look back on.

Karen, I love that your kids ask permission to use that bathroom. That's just super. lol.

Ptolemy said...

@Ellen - actually, I've learned through MY experience that boys will "fire" you, too -- same age. But they forgive your infractions, however invisible they might be to you, within moments. I suspect girls hang on longer.

Sophie XIV said...

As to not wanting to be seen with 'the weird kid' I have only one thing to say: it's sad, and disgusting, and when you'r the kid on the recieving end it hurts like hell, but at least children are equal opportunity discriminators. The kid in the wheelchair, the shy kid, the mentally disabled kid, the Chinese kid, the kid who has two moms, the kid who lives with his grandparents, the foster kid, the kid who 'forgets' his lunch every day, the kid who wears her sisters clothes- all are treated with equal distain. You just reminded me why I hated elementary school so much. Also, re the 'frenemy' that happens so much and it's depressing. WHy is it that backstabbing your own friends seems to be a uniquely female trait?

Gwensarah said...

Alot of Rymer's friends have always been girls and he was always bewhildered by the whole "I'm not your friend anymore" thing. I remember having to explain the whole girl warfare thing to him. I believe he said "well that's stupid." Of course this will make him an excellent listener to his own daughter someday (or even to his little sister since she is 10 1/2 years younger) having served in the trenches himself so to speak.

Sherry said...

lollol! "Fucknuts"!! Too funny!

I started calling stupid drivers "Jacknut" when my two tiny sets of ears were accompanying me in the car. It just came out of my mouth one day in a moment of frustration. I'm not sure exactly how this term came about but I'm guessing it was my attempt to combine "Jackass" and "Numbnuts" while maintaining a "G" rating. Not quite as satisfying to say... but it's close.

christopher said...

Knowing that I teach in elementary school, you understand that there are no words more cruel or forbidden than "stupid". I have come to believe that no person under 18 should *ever* be called stupid.

My sense is that by the time you have become an adult, you have earned the right to own your prejudices or ignorance. But before that day, you are protected and given grace to show that you have learned what it means to be a caring and thoughtful citizen of this planet.

Anonymous said...

Do we hold special needs kids to a higher standard? Most kids would get away with this kind of behavior because they can be sneakier or because adults accept that its common behavior. They are bugging each other- it's balanced and reciprocal. We dont want to approve of it of course but I dont see any results of punishment. Maybe someone should consider what is inspiring this rivalry? Or have the kids call a truce? Or have the kids collaborate on a project whenever they fight?

mooserbeans said...

Girls are tricky. Boys just hit each other and it is over. Girls go for the juggular. One minute they love each other, the next they are fighting. Look at some of the book the American Girl Company publishes. They have a good one on navigating friendships.

Anonymous said...

So the dad book is on hold. Has another project taken its place?

Anonymous said...

hi~
as a mom of twin girls (3.5yrs)... I would say Schulyer pretty much has her 'sister'. I do think girls are meaner. My love-lies tell me all the time, I don't love you anymore. I just say 'well I love you and that will have to be enough' They call each other 'bad' all the time. I do tell them it's not nice to call people names, but.... We want them to be lovely all the time and it just isn't possible. btw~ one of my twins gets excluded because she's taller than everyone in her class. go figure!

Anonymous said...

My daughter had a frenemy like that in kindergarten last year. Her very wise teacher sat them down together and had them find something they both liked in common. Then she had them bring those toys in to school and they played with them together at free time for a week. They're best friends now and they no longer beat each other up in the bathroom:)

Rich said...

For the record I hate the word SpEd... Heres my post about it: http://tinyurl.com/q4kqf9 - But, I'll let you slide, just this once... :-)

Rob Rummel-Hudson said...

For the record I hate the word SpEd... Heres my post about it: http://tinyurl.com/q4kqf9 - But, I'll let you slide, just this once... :-)

Well, I've never heard it used the way you're talking about, I've only see it used as a shorthand for Special Education. I personally find the word "special" to be distasteful in this context, and I'd stop using it altogether if I thought I could get away with it.

I'll probably keep using it, sorry. If I start trying to use language that never offends anyone ever, I won't be able to write another word. Even People First Language is offensive... to me.

Rich said...

No problem Rob... :) Love the blog!